Skip to main content

Taming Advice Monsters While Mentoring

Photo by Yaopey Yong on Unsplash

Let me introduce you to the advice monster that I got to know in Michael Bungay Stanier’s TED talk “How to tame your advice monster”. Imagine someone asking you for advice. Before they even finish explaining the problem, your advice monster awakens already waiting for its turn to burst out all the brilliant advice. That advice monster is convinced that you know the situation well even if you may not have the full context at all. 

When we think of a mentor, we often expect someone who is capable of giving great advice. We may also become mentors because we feel we have enough experience, passion, and ability to advise people. However, mentoring is much more complex than simply providing advice. And, mentoring environments usually are extremely satiating spots for advice monsters. For a better mentoring experience we need to tame our advice monsters.

Mentoring requests often start with a small description of a person’s challenges and often it ends with a question: “What could you advise me?”. The advice monster of a mentor can get euphoric here - it already knows what to say. It grasps bits and pieces that are familiar and already has all the magnificent advice ready. However, it’s so easy to slip into believing that you understand the problem, the person, and all the complexities. Likely it’s not as straight-forward as we tend to believe. 

You may say all the advice out, and… not help the person at all. Why? Because there’s a high chance you don’t understand the problem you’re trying to advise on.

Get to know the real challenges

I have had different mentoring sessions: in some of them my advice monster was uneasy and kept throwing in ideas, while in others it was quiet, tamed, and the sessions felt more like therapy to mentees. Both types could be useful depending on the person you’re talking to. An active advice monster can be beneficial, too, if you are certain that you understand the problem. Then it’s absolutely alright to brainstorm with your mentee what could help there. 

Make sure to spend some time to really get to the core of the problem a person may be facing. That can be done only by active listening and asking questions. Don’t just straight jump into giving advice. 

As Michael Bungay Stanier said:

“The problem isn’t about giving advice, it’s when giving advice is our default response.”

Embrace active listening

Advice monsters are quite terrible at listening, but if we make them listen better - the more we know, the better even the repertoire of the advice monster’s data can be. 

Best mentoring is never a one-way engagement. It requires both mentor and mentee to sometimes switch roles. We need to create a safe environment where both can ask, share, and grow. Just providing advice without listening or creating a safe space out of the blue is even dangerous and can be harming a mentee: they may consider themselves less than, it may even disempower them. That is the least we want from a mentoring session.

Listening and full attention is a gift. Try to remember the last time someone gave you their full attention. How did it make you feel? Very likely, you felt appreciated, respected, and heard out. 

You can add value not only by telling, but listening and just being there for a person, too. They may even feel more empowered by that and proceed to brainstorm some great solutions to their challenges themselves.

Stay curious longer

Lastly, the best advice is when the person asking for advice and the person giving it come to it together. For that, as a mentor, you have to stay curious longer. Michael Bungay Stanier recommends three questions that can help you guide the conversation:

  1. What’s the real challenge here for you?
    This is a focus question which repositions you to understand what is an actual issue. 

  2. And what else?
    This question can be asked multiple times. Dig deeper into the issue. This will lead you to what the real challenge is. The first answer is rarely the best answer. 

  3. What do you want?
    I love this question because it allows you to understand what is the vision of the person asking for advice. They may not be courageous enough right now to reach it and you can try to help them get out there.

In conclusion

Watch out for unprepared advice monsters taking over when you’re trying to give advice. The best advice is generated by taming your advice monster. Get to know the real challenges the person is facing, listen actively, and stay curious with questions. 

Written by Lina Zubyte


  1. Great, very relevant post. Thanks!

  2. There is a value exchange in listening. Absolutely true!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Probably one of the most simple and extremely effective tools for managers

One of the topics that I discussed with quite some mentees via the Mentoring Club is how to manage managers and what tools and frameworks I would suggest in order to build strong relationships with everyone in my team.
One tool that I established in my teams last year is a "User Guide" for working with me. Yes right: I wrote a document that describes several aspects of how I would like to work, about my expectations but also my flaws. I gave this document to all my team leads and senior team members as a reference. 
With this article I publish the contents of my 'user guide' together with some explanations. You should take your time to reflect about what is important for you. List everything that comes to your mind, try to get to the root of everything. In a second step put yourself into the shoes of whoever works with you. What might be important to them? Why should they know? What do you want them to be 100% aligned with? What would they need from you in order to m…

9 perspectives on why the corona pandemic will have a positive impact

The Mentoring Club is an initiative that was founded when the corona pandemic hit the german and european business world. The two founders (Jessica & Bastian) actually started this initiative because their employer needed to reduce the amount of work for almost everyone to massively reduce costs. In just a few days there were many other people who asked to join and in not even two month time The Mentoring Club counts almost 70 mentors from around the world, who already donated about 200 hours of free mentoring, support and counseling to others. 

One positive side effect of corona is indeed that the humanity as a whole and the business world showed a very positive and humble face. We asked our mentors what they think how the pandemic might have a positive effect on businesses and organisations. Read here what nine of them think. 
Do you agree? Do you see other aspects? Please add as a comment below!

"In CORONA times, even the most conservative managers were pushed to try remote w…

Let’s talk about women in leadership

By Monique Zytnik
I’ve been inspired by the amazing female leaders on the global stage who have coolly and effectively handled the recent crisis and are still negotiating, supporting and inspiring others as their countries head on the road to recovery. I see these leaders as role models.However, looking at numbers of women in leadership roles last year we still have a way to go to achieve fair representation. This year the outlook is grimmer. Many social commentators fear that women have just taken a giant leap backwards and under the increased family and social strain are less likely to put their hands up for leadership roles. What do you think?